Design lab

rounds/r3/s10-frontend-design-skill/notes.md

s10 (frontend-design skill): Vienna Family Dental homepage

Concept, in one line: the neighborhood practice on Maple Avenue, told in photographs: a family morning, real Vienna, the real team as one wall of faces, and real smiles, with the logo's own blue as a bold flat fill.

Main decisions

No cream, navy or gold.

Photos used

Placeholders and calls I made

With better assets or more time

The guide: where it helped, where it got in the way

Helped:

Got in the way or left me guessing:

The review loop

It helped a lot: from 7 to 8 overall, with the phone and booking-path scores moving most. The points that mattered most:

1. Round 1, Kadie's quote sat beside the makeover photos, implying a false identity. This was the most important catch: a facts problem I couldn't see. 2. Round 1, the booking path on desktop: the sticky header, plus Book in the hours, sedation and paying panels. 3. Round 1, the phone dock covered the hero's buttons on the first screen. 4. Round 3, a footer regression I introduced in round 2 by adding a grid rule with no media query, which crushed the phone footer.

The crops (hero, makeover) took two passes each. The reviewer was good at precise numbers, and once suggested a nose-down crop the source photo couldn't give.

All three rounds ended "another round". I fixed the round-3 points without a fourth review, as REVIEW.md caps it at three.